28 April 2009 - Social Security fixes

< yesterday -- tomorrow >

Slanting the Proposals

People who know what they’re doing, unless they are desperately poor, can save for retirement on their own; having a government program trying to help only makes life harder. But research shows that most people still keep the same financial literacy that Neanderthals learned after trading was first invented.

There are two approaches. If you believe people are basically smart but perhaps ignorant on selected subjects, like you, then private retirement accounts plus education solve the problem. If you think people are incorrigibly stupid, like you, then it’s time to go all Fidel Castro on ’em.

clue:

Americans talk about political differences as if they were only differences in values. But they also include differences in how people believe the world works.

The Neanderthal quip is only a small exaggeration! It may be human nature not to think much about the long term, in which case a paternalistic government solution is best. I can’t tell.

take oh take this clue away

the Daily Whale || copyright 2009, 2024 Jay J.P. Scott <jay@satirist.org>